Created: september 4, 2025
Created: Drs. Jessica Terwiel
Published in the public domain. This flowchart may be freely distributed and used for informational and educational purposes related to fact-finding and investigation. It may not be used for purely commercial purposes. It must always be displayed in its entirety with the creator’s name included. The creator is not responsible or liable for any improper or bad faith use of this image.

The Epistemic Cycle, hereafter EC, is a flowchart. This flowchart illustrates how to separate facts from falsehoods in a complex case. It is therefore a representation of the methodical approach of fact-finding.
In investigative work (e.g., police work), it’s called “scenario-based approach.” In psychological and medical diagnostics, it’s called “differential diagnostic procedure.”
In the healthcare and protection services for minors, fact-finding is currently rarely applied. That’s why I developed the Epistemic Cycle for educational purposes in this area. The fact-finding method is visually represented in the flowchart.
So, the Cycle applies to fact-finding, regardless of the line of work you’re involved in. If you’re looking to extract facts from a large amount of data, this image illustrates in broad terms how that works.
The blue cloud full of “data” contains everything you have access to in your case. This cloud grows almost daily as new actions and interactions occur, documents arrive, emails are sent and received, and so on. Everything is contained in this cloud, and it’s all jumbled together. The truths and the untruths, the clarity and the ambiguity, the contradictions, and so on. Everything in the cloud always counts in some way or other.
Until you know what the truth is, multiple stories are possible: multiple scenarios. At the very least, you always have two scenarios in mind: “A is true” and “A is not true.” The first scenario involves a number of facts that are not true in the other scenario, and the other scenario involves a number of facts that are not true in the first scenario.
Ultimately, there’s only one true scenario. All others are false. In order to discover the true scenario, one must therefore try to eliminate all false scenarios.
In order to rule out scenarios, choose contradictions that can’t both be true. At least one of the two is false, and you might be able to demonstrate that. Start with if-then thinking. For example: “If he’s made a reservation, then he should have the confirmation email to show for it.”
A simple way to explore contradictions is to choose an accusation. Every accusation is either true or false. If the accusation is true, then the accused has done something wrong. If the accusation is false, then the person making the accusation is lying.
Sometimes you already have data that can show which of the scenarios is not true. If-then: If that scenario is not true, then you know that some other things cannot be true either. If-then: If he wasn’t in Vancouver that week, then he wasn’t visiting my uncle in Vancouver that week.
In order to determine which of your options is false, you often need to take further action. To do research. To try something. This means you choose to perform a specific interaction with your case. For example, you might have a conversation with someone you want to ask a few questions. Or you might send an email. Or you might make a request. Someone responds to your action, so your blue cloud grows. You now know how that person reacted. This information might tell you a little more about what is not true. Now you can continue with the remaining options: what else might or might not be true.
This is how you constantly cycle through your cycle, always keeping if-then options in mind. Sometimes, six scenarios are eliminated in a single conversation because the person has very useful answers, allowing you to eliminate a lot. Sometimes, you spend months researching and trying to ensure you can eliminate just one scenario. The cycle repeats until you have a well-rounded story about what must be true (because all other options have been eliminated, and you can prove that) and how that story unfolded (a moment of truth isn’t enough; you also have to be able to explain the entire history up to that point).
As you can see, applying the cycle effectively requires a wide range of skills. These include logical and analytical reasoning about your if-then options; skills in conducting research; skills in interacting with key individuals in the case; skills in documenting your findings so others can gain insight into your analytical process and the necessary next steps; and so on.
The cycle doesn’t demonstrate all these skills. You’ll have to learn them in your vocational training or continuing education. The cycle simply shows you how to apply them and how to arrive at the correct diagnosis/true scenario by eliminating options.